Reply #100 anne_aqil's post
anne,anak minah yg second dah 2 tahun baru start cakap... sebelum tu satu patah perkataaan pun dia tak tau cakap.. not even mama, mommy etc...
Sekarang dia baru nak masuk 2 tahun 2 bulan.. barulah dah dengar die cakap sikit2..lega rasanya bila dia start nak bukak mulut bercakap...
Don't worry la anne.. budak2 perkembangan lain2.. nanti bila dah naik darjah 1 baru sama level diaorang... setahu me kan...sekolah medium english atau tidak, cikgu cakap english atau tidak kurang kesannya berbanding dgn peer group anak2 tu sendiri....
byk beza antara anak2 yg dihantar ke english medium tapi kawan2 sebaya takleh cakap english...berbanding dgn sekolah yg multiraces, anak terpaksa cakap english....w/pun cikgu mereka cakap dwi-bahasa...
kawan me sendiri pernah mengajar satu kindergarten, hanya dia cakap english...sedangkan anak2 sesama mereka cakap melayu...akhirnya cikgu kena cakap dwi-bahasa, sebab anak2 tak paham arahan...
contoh smart reader putrajaya, semua cakap melayu w/pun medium english....anak2 sesama mereka pun cakap melayu...itu sebab byk mak/ayah sannggup hantar ke CEC sebab peer group kat sini berbeza kalau sha ..sha preferQ-Dees dr smart reader..
sbb ikut experince kawan2..sume said Q-Dees lagi better..
Nuri pun bagus jgk.. Originally posted by sha_n at 31-5-2007 04:29 PM
kalau sha ..sha preferQ-Dees dr smart reader..
sbb ikut experince kawan2..sume said Q-Dees lagi better..
Nuri pun bagus jgk..
kenapa?...takpe kita kongsi2 personal view:loveliness:
me tak suka sebab q-dees yg me lawat haritu, buat kat rumah teres 2 tingkat...masa me pi lawat...anak2 berlari up and down the stairs(takde gate)....depa boleh kumpul budak2 seramai 25 org dlm bilik master bedroom utk tujuan mengajar...kawasan q-dees takde gate, kussss semangat tgk dia letak slide tepi main road:( ....
just wonder, adakah mereka dapat pengesahan drp jabatan bomba dan kebajikan masyarakat.... bahaya lh camtu.. my son goes to smart reader since last yr (now he is 6)
last yr reading skill dia mmg 2 level behind his friends le..
aku wat derk je walaupon cikgu dia suruh 'we do something about it'
aku malas nak push2 sgt budak tu sebab aku tau bukannye dia tak pick up, cume dia malas nak focus je.. (he has mild ADHD)... lagi pon aku mmg MALAS.. (I myself suffer from ADHD..heh heh heh)
even early this yr pon haram tak membaca sgt pon.....until bulan 3 bulan 4 bebaru ni dia tetiba lancar..can read all the signboards..all the tv programmes shown on the tv screen and words in ads... alhamdulillah..
as for english... he went in with 0 english capabity...even aku , hasben..grandparents dia and auntie dia cakap egnlish dgn dia pon he never picked up.... tp now dia dah bercakap byk gak in english..walaupon most of the time berterabur .. thanks to the little cute girl who sits next to him in class who also happens to speak 100% english... so member tak nak malu dia paksa gak la bercakap omputeh dgn awek tu... :lol: :lol:
Reply #102 my-alja's post
My-alja,I agree with you.. minah dah reply kat thread u yg lagi satu pasal perkembangan anak minah masa kat CEC and Q'dees.. It is all because of the environment anak minah daripada pandai cakap english bila tukar ke Q'dees langsung2 taknak (bukan tak tau..) cakap english.. He can read (now dah reach to Reading book 8), spell but not converse in English.. :( :(
Tapi semalam masa minah tengah kemas2 baju nak hantar anak2 balik kampung, tiba2 anak minah ni dtg kat minah tanya.. "Mom, where are we going..?". Pas tu minah jawab la.. Nenek's house.. Then anak minah ni boleh cakap kat minah.."Mom, see I can speak English already.." Hahaha.. :lol: :lol:Sabo je la anak aku tu.. ye kann minah...persekitaran anak2 byk mempengaruhi mereka, my son balik sini, cakap english dah jadi slang chinese..."my one, your one"..bila bercakap dgn adik dia;P .... tu tak masuk lagi dgn tambahan..."laaa"....
dulu dia tanya kenapa cikgu dia cakap english ada "laaaa"...sekarang dia plak yg ngikut, selalulah kena tegur dia ...(mak pun tersasul memanjang)...
kekadang bila ada masa me saja bukak citer harry porter, nak lari drp slang american(byk sgt tgkl disney channel):loveliness: hi sumer...
my eldest now pre-2 kat Q-dees pandan indah..
so far so gud..
tapi.. lawak nyer.. klu numbering tuh.. calculation especially.. sumer in english la.. tapi bile kita test sket dia in bahasa.. sure dia ckp.. 'ma.. salah la...'
for example kan..
calculation gini... 2 + 2 = 4..
dia akan sebut gini.. thwooooo (slang lagikk wakakakkakaka) plus thwoooooo equal four.
klu kita test dia.. danish.. tu bukan ke dua campur dua sama dengan empat.. lajuuu je dia jawab.. bukan ma.. salah.. then he will correct me cam dia nyer 'style' la.. huhuhuhuhu
[ Last edited bysofeya at 5-6-2007 12:09 PM ]
Q-dees or smart reader yg mana lg elok?
i nak hantar anak i nxt year. umo dia 5 yrs taun dpn.. tp tak pasti mana lg elok.? so mintak tolong saper2 yg ader pengalaman hantar anak ke q-dees or smartreader tolong bg pendapat..tq aku ader kawan keje q-dees. tapi takleh nak tolon tuan umah sbb tak pernah ader pengalaman psl Q-dees VS Smartreaders :sweat3: yang eloknya u pergi dulu kat sekolah/centre tu. tanya dgn detail baru compare. ingat..lain anak lain tahap kecerdasannya. of course kalau u dah spend so much your expectation also will be very highkan.q-dees or smart reader memasing ada progaram/curriculum derang sendiri.tak bermakna kalau u hantar anak ke tadika biasa anak u tak akan jadi pandai.smart reader punye fees pun boleh tahan RM1800 for 4 months. q-dees tak pasti berapa sure dlm lingkungan tu gak. i rase dua2 elok...my daughter from kindergarten amek SR (only English subject)...up to darjah tiga still tuition english SR with the kindergarten teacher...naik darjah 4 dia kepenatan (tuition class malam) sbb dia dah start dgn ko-ku activities kat skolah and also sekolah agama (gasping for breath mama katanye..kesian jugakk)...walaupun dah berhenti.....dia maintain this par 95 - 100 % for every english paper...tqs to SR..imagine kalau your kids ambik yang fulltime/full syllabus..:$ ..goodluck aah... mmg dh servey dh... smart readers dgn qdees sama jer lebih kurang harga nyer.. tp biler dgr2 org ckp.. walaupon kinder tu english medium.. kalo ramai melayu nnt ckp melayu gak.. so fobia la.. bkn pe takut tak pandai gak ckp english.. yelah, niat nak hantar tu pon mmg nak suh la dia pandai ckp english..:( aah... mmg dh servey dh... smart readers dgn qdees sama jer lebih kurang harga nyer.. tp biler dgr2 org ckp.. walaupon kinder tu english medium.. kalo ramai melayu nnt ckp melayu gak.. so fobia la.. bkn pe takut tak pandai gak ckp english.. yelah, niat nak hantar tu pon mmg nak suh la dia pandai ckp english..:( ma prefer SR.:) kalu anta SR or Q-dees...boleh yer kita amik english jer...?umur bape ye boleh start anta?umur anak anim skrg 2 tahun.... da ade kot topik nih..:loveliness: :)
leh refer thread nih..:) :) :)
http://forum3.cari.com.my/viewthread.php?tid=187326&extra=page%3D5&sercari=9 my son 6 y.o masuk SR awal thn aritu. adik dia pun masuk sam 4 y.o. dia start fr level 1 sbb teacher takut dia pandai lagi since dia masuk time umo 6 thn. kwn2 yg lain mostly drp umo 4/5 thn. 90% non-malay kat SR tu sbb kaw. i ni kat kepong kan..faham2 jeklah. Ade yg i suka ada gak yg tak suka ttg smart reader ni. Mula2, suka sbb:
1. teacher dia commited. Sbb my son have 2 start fr lvl 1, so teacher dia buat intensive 'course' utk my son- 1 to 1. Jadinya, skang ni kira kalo soh baca buku, dah terelah. Ada words yg tak tau sebut tp rasanya dia lbh tere compared dgn i masa sekolah tadika dulu.
2. tak tau nak ckp apa lagi yg best..ooo...sbb mostly non-malay, so they conversed in englih. tp kat ghumah, haram sepatah pun tak ckp bi dgn makpak or siblings...cuma kdg2 diorang converse in english bila tgh main2 sama2. but i know they can speak english well sbb bila terjumpa classmates, my son akan berbual in english.
yg tak best:
1. aku soh teacher masukkan my kids dlm mandarin class, hampeh...langsung depa tak masukkan..balik2 bg alasan, diorang akan dpt catch up bila dah mix around with other chinese friends..aku kata, masukkan jek dlm class mandarin tu. tak payahlah tulis2, just listen jek so that my kids tau camane nak berckp mandarin...agaknya diorang takmo org2 melayu ni tere ckp mandarin..susah nak umpat kot..ntahlaa..kalo psl fees, mintak jeklah kat we all. tapi tak...
2. kelas kat shop lot. if ikut rules n regulation jkm ke hapa..tadika/nursery mmg tak blh buat kat shop lot atas sbb2 keselamatan i believe. yelah, if berlaku kebakaran ke apa, kan susah nak selamatkan budak2 esp kat tkt 1 or above! tapi sbb depa guna nama Pusat Perkembangan Minda..jadinya, they get away with it...parents pun takde yg report sbb nak sgt hantar anak ke SR...
3. kat tpt my kids tu takde fardhu ain sbb principal chinese..so..minus point there..IMHO, kalo tere ckp english pun, kalo dr kecik tak diajar bab2 akidah, akhlak sbg org Islam..susah jugak. bahasa tu insyaAllah blh diajar lg..tp kalo akhlak dr kecik dah tak betul...susah nak dibentuk..ntahlaa ye..my son masa 4 y.o sekolah PASTI, pandailah baca surah2 lazim, solat etc...nasib baik dia bawak ilmu tu sampai skang. compared 2 his sister...susah gak nak ajar doter tu...jd tugas parents tu lbh challenging lah sbb anak2 mudah belajo dgn guru dan rakan2..
kalo bab makan duit, SR pun kuat makan gak..tu sbb mid year, i kuarkan my doter fr SR...tak tertanggung beban nak membayo..takpelaa...ada 2 th lagi..maybe nak sekolahkan kat tadika Islam bawah umah je...baru bukak..part english..learn fr Astro....rasanya lbh mudah depa catch up drp situ..vocab pun blh tahan..anak2 my freinds siap ckp english with british accent lagi..sume belajo fr cartoon..
pjg dah karangan ni..sowie kalo ada melalut... anak tina,dua2 dari Smart Reader Kids Bandar Baru Bangi.Principle nya Puan Wati.Bagi Tina,memang bagus.nampak keberkesanan.Tina memang puas hati sangat....