CARI Infonet

 Forgot password?
 Register

ADVERTISEMENT

Author: Acong

[Jenayah] FITNAH KES BANK ISLAM TERHADAP KHALID IBRAHIM DIJAWAB

[Copy link]
Post time 21-8-2014 01:51 PM | Show all posts
Maideen. posted on 21-8-2014 01:29 PM
Sebenarnya kes Khalid ini melibatkan lebih kurang Khalid jual saham miliknya kepada Bank Isle dan  ...

saya ni bukan bidang ekonomi syariah Maideen....tapi nak lebih jelas...pengalaman Maideen..siapa yg salah sebenarnya?.

jual saham, beli saham balik..struktur balik.  .bukan ke jual beli kali kedua tu..mesti penjual dan pembeli tandatangani transaksi tu?..ke main boh je?..ish tak faham AN Maideen..
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 21-8-2014 02:07 PM | Show all posts
badaksumbu posted on 21-8-2014 01:09 PM
ni katanya org tengah tu,

if tak silap, if dia menang kes tu, pelanggan lain yg pakai T&C same mcm dia pun leh menang kes. dlm law if tak silap, ada term utk kes2 camni, something precedence, saya bukan pelajar law.

did some google search, I think it's called binding precedent. if salah, mintak betulkan. Last edited by blackred99 on 21-8-2014 02:13 PM

Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 21-8-2014 02:20 PM | Show all posts
blackred99 posted on 21-8-2014 02:07 PM
if tak silap, if dia menang kes tu, pelanggan lain yg pakai T&C same mcm dia pun leh menang kes. d ...

pemimjam lain boleh saman Bank Islam dgn menggunakan kes TSKI sbg reference. tak kucar kacir Bank Islam?

Bank Islam tu sebenarnya musang berbulu ayam
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 02:33 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Maideen. posted on 21-8-2014 01:29 PM
Sebenarnya kes Khalid ini melibatkan lebih kurang Khalid jual saham miliknya kepada Bank Isle dan  ...

Haha... Member aku ada buat loan....dia nak buat apa ntah...tp bank tulih situ pembiayaan pelaburan kelapa sawit...member heran sejak bila plak dia terlibat dgn sawit ni....
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:09 PM | Show all posts
Anak_Nogori posted on 21-8-2014 01:51 PM
saya ni bukan bidang ekonomi syariah Maideen....tapi nak lebih jelas...pengalaman Maideen..siapa y ...

Itulah masalah yang menyelubungi ummah kini AN. Penggunaan akal dikalangan ummah amat tidak di galakan. Ungkapan ungkapan seperti " Akal kita hanya setitik jika dibandingkan dengan lautan ilmu Allah tawww" atau "Ulamak Pewaris Nabi tawwww dan oleh itu kita musti gunakan akal ulamak sahaja tawww!" dsbnya, sering di ungkapkan oleh oleh orang yang menaku mereka ulamak "yakni alim atau berilmu".

Maka ummah pon hanya mampu bertaklid (yakni ikut saja apa kata orang secara membabi buta). Mula mula bertaklid dengan Muhammad Idris (aka Imam Shafie). Ni bila Muhammad Idris dah meninggal, bertaklid pula dengan lobai lobai sarban janggut - kalau baru balik dari Mesir lagi hebat dan kalau baru balik dari Mesir pakai sarban dan membawa tasbih yang buahnya dibuat daripada bola ping pong, lagi lah disanjung. Mereka ini cari makan AN, kita kena faham tu. Selagi ada orang kagum dengan mereka, maka berterusan mereka aurat kehulu aurat kehilir, syumul kesana syumul kemari, sikit sikit hukum Allah sikit sikit hukum Allah, ber tahaful siyasi kesana bahalol habisi kemari!

Cukup mukadimah......

Didalam hal perbankan Islam pula, kita di malaya bertaklidkan dengan "fekah" (yakni "pemahaman" Muhammad Idris aka Imam Shafie). Imam Shafie sundri dilaporkan berkata "Jangan ambik dari aku tapi ambik dari apa yang aku ambik kerana aku mungkin silap!" Imam Shafie sundri pada pendapat Maideen adalah seorang yang mengambil secara literal. Pernah Maideen bagi contoh scenario ini:

Seorang lelaki menjual kepada seorang lobai (yang bini bini balik kampong semuanya) seorang hamba wanita miliknya ditangga masjid, selepas Isyak. Katalah harga jualannya 1000 dirham. Lobai itu bersetuju untuk menjual hamba wanita itu semula kepada lelaki itu hamba wanita tersebut sebanyak 500 dirham keesokan harinya selepas mereka sembahyang suboh!

Harus lah perbuatan ini dilihat sebagai jual beli yang sah di sisi Shariah oleh Imam Shafie di masakini dan bukannya transaksi memperdagan manusia! Ini kerana Imam Shafie tidak melihat langsung akan niat kedua pihak tersebut! dalam pemahaman beliau jika perjanjian jual beli itu sah (siap dengan segala rukunnya termasuk aqadnya) maka sah lah perbuatan itu! (Mungkin kita boleh renungkan fekah Imam Shafie tentang cara membayar zakat fitrah yang betul.)

Nah! Ini BBA dimana lu jual sama wa dan wa jual balik, dalam fekah Imam Shafie adalah patuh Shariah. Tapi di jurisdiksi lain di mana orang bertaklid kat Imam lain, ianya di lihat sebagai suatu "hilah" sahaja dan mungkin hamya mahu menipu Allah SWT sahaja. Itu sebab ianya di kritik dan dikecam hebat! tapi ulamak ulamak Malaya hanya mampu berkata "Hehehe....hehehehe....sumua mazhab betul maaaa!", sesambil tersipu sipu!

Jadinya bila AN bertanya siapa salah, yang sebenernya ummah yang salah. Tak mampu berfikir, cepat melatah bila ditunjukan kebodohan, tapi perasan bagus dan orang kagum! malah ada pula yang mengatakan Yahudi dan Nasroni dengki!

Itulah keadaan dan masa yang kita hidup didalamnya sekarang ini. Orang kampong Maideen hanya mampu berkata " O tempora! o mores!"

Wallahualam.
Last edited by Maideen. on 21-8-2014 03:38 PM

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:19 PM | Show all posts
Maideen. posted on 21-8-2014 01:29 PM
Sebenarnya kes Khalid ini melibatkan lebih kurang Khalid jual saham miliknya kepada Bank Isle dan  ...

I had just purchased another house M. The bank asked me do I want islamic loan. I said no. I remember your posts in here. They quoted me a much higher rate, its just that the rate wont change.

The fact is they have incorporated everything and I think I will be paying more.

Islamic la sangat.

Reply

Use magic Report

Follow Us
Post time 21-8-2014 03:23 PM | Show all posts
honeybee1802 posted on 21-8-2014 02:33 PM
Haha... Member aku ada buat loan....dia nak buat apa ntah...tp bank tulih situ pembiayaan pelabura ...

Itu namanya "tabaruK" ka apa kaka. Ianya di rekacipata dengan membabitkan orang ketiga. Jika "Lu jual sama wa, wa jual sama lu balik", nampak sangat menipu Allah SWT, kita babitkan orang ketiga dan barang yang dijual beli itu adalah dari pasaran yang halal ia itu kernal kelapa sawait!

Mungkin bila cara iniu dilakukan, Allah SWT tak lah perasan sangat.

Wallahualam.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:23 PM | Show all posts
blackred99 posted on 21-8-2014 02:07 PM
if tak silap, if dia menang kes tu, pelanggan lain yg pakai T&C same mcm dia pun leh menang kes. d ...

pun google jugak n jumpa term legal precedent. precedent tak precedent, kalau tanya sy yg bkn student law ni, tiga2 pihak yg terlibat dlm settlement ni mmg x berintergriti/x bermoral. mcm kes kantoi la pulak.

Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 21-8-2014 03:24 PM | Show all posts
truly posted on 21-8-2014 03:19 PM
I had just purchased another house M. The bank asked me do I want islamic loan. I said no. I remem ...

Well done! Tapi besok menjawab lah you kat "sana"......
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:25 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Maideen. posted on 21-8-2014 03:09 PM
Itulah masalah yang menyelubungi ummah kini AN. Penggunaan akal dikalangan ummah amat tidak di gal ...

I baru ingat nak berhutang balik...ingat nak guna Islamic loan...adakah semua bank yg mengamalkan Islamic financing ni sama dgn bank Islam...kalau ya patutlah bank Mata sepet pun ada guna islamic namr
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:28 PM | Show all posts
Maideen. posted on 21-8-2014 03:24 PM
Well done! Tapi besok menjawab lah you kat "sana"......

I ada jugak terfikir, adakah ni bermaksud I menolak Islam tapi I rasa tak apa lah, balik rumah I bertaubat. Lagipun keadaaan masa tu adalah dhorurat.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:30 PM | Show all posts
scorpionkiki posted on 21-8-2014 03:25 PM
I baru ingat nak berhutang balik...ingat nak guna Islamic loan...adakah semua bank yg mengamalkan  ...

Jangankan mata sepet bro. Yang mata biru kokusyen pon nak buat. Yerlah, orang semua nak patuh "syariah" kan . Rasanya Islam tidak melarang kafir laknatullah  buat duit sikit....

Orang Isle pon buleh lah mendabik dada dan berkata " See? Orang kafir laknatullah pon nampak keindahan Isle tawww! Cam tu baru tahaful siyasi! "

Wallahualam.
Last edited by Maideen. on 21-8-2014 03:32 PM

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:36 PM | Show all posts
Maideen. posted on 21-8-2014 03:09 PM
Itulah masalah yang menyelubungi ummah kini AN. Penggunaan akal dikalangan ummah amat tidak di gal ...

OH..gitu Maideen...baru faham..terima kasih.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:36 PM | Show all posts
highcastle posted on 21-8-2014 06:12 AM
Mencari kesalahan Khalid yang tidak wujud amat mudah dijumpai akan tetapi mencari kesalahan Ketum ya ...

Sorang mabuk ketum. Habis semua terpalit.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 03:46 PM | Show all posts
truly posted on 21-8-2014 03:28 PM
I ada jugak terfikir, adakah ni bermaksud I menolak Islam tapi I rasa tak apa lah, balik rumah I b ...

Ha.....dhorurat kalu, kira okay lah.....
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 07:43 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
scorpionkiki posted on 21-8-2014 03:25 PM
I baru ingat nak berhutang balik...ingat nak guna Islamic loan...adakah semua bank yg mengamalkan  ...

Ada jua islamic pakai bfr which is sama kot ngan blr..tp ada ceiling...
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 21-8-2014 08:27 PM | Show all posts
As banker saya respect TSKI, kalau dia tak nak bayar sesen pun hutang dengan Bank Islam pun boleh tapi masih buat out of court settlement.

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 08:51 PM | Show all posts



Published: Thursday August 21, 2014 MYT 7:02:00 PM
Updated: Thursday August 21, 2014 MYT 7:17:22 PM
Selangor MB crisis: Meeting on Bank Islam deal a 'waste of time', says Khalid Samad

BY RAHMAH GHAZALI

SHAH ALAM: Shah Alam PAS MP Khalid Samad said that a meeting he had with Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim's lawyers in a bid to seek the truth behind the embattled Mentri Besar's Bank Islam out-of-court settlement was a failure and a "waste of time".

At a press conference here Thursday, he said the two-hour meeting last Saturday with Khalid Ibrahim's lawyers Mathew Thomas and Derek Fernandez, was "virtually a waste of time" as it raised even more questions.

The meeting, he said, was arranged by Khalid Ibrahim as PAS was willing to be the mediator between him and PKR in an attempt to clear his name.

He said Thomas, who represented Khalid Ibrahim in the Bank Islam case, confirmed that there was an out-of-court settlement over a RM70mil loan, but the details could not be revealed.

"The details of the out-of-court settlement could not be revealed unless they received a green light from Khalid Ibrahim.

"He just told us that Khalid Ibrahim made some payment to Bank Islam, but he couldn't tell us the amount involved," said Khalid Samad, who was accompanied by PAS' lawyer and treasurer Asmuni Awi.

On Tuesday, The Star Online reported that Khalid Samad had met with Khalid Ibrahim's lawyers where he denied he was satisfied with the outcome of the meeting.

Khalid Samad said they were merely assured that the settlement was "above board" but the lawyers said they were "not at liberty to provide the details".

"Our meeting ended with our questions remained unanswered although we were promised that the meeting was aimed to explain everything," he said.

He said now the onus is on Khalid Ibrahim to come clean and clear his name from accusations that he was "compromised" and "bought over" by his former PKR colleagues.

"Asmuni and I were willing to sign a non-disclosure agreement, if needed, if we could be provided with the details verifying that the out-of-court settlement was truly above board.

"If that was the truth, we would say to his friends in PKR that there was no case against Khalid Ibrahim and would advise them to stop attacking him.

"Unfortunately, this opportunity has gone to waste," he said, adding that to date, Khalid Ibrahim has yet to allow his lawyers release the details of the settlement.

Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 21-8-2014 09:16 PM | Show all posts
Maideen. posted on 21-8-2014 03:46 PM
Ha.....dhorurat kalu, kira okay lah.....

maideen, beli byk rumah guna loan conventional macam mana? beli byk2 bukan darurat dah kan?
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-8-2014 09:35 PM | Show all posts
Acong posted on 21-8-2014 09:16 PM
maideen, beli byk rumah guna loan conventional macam mana? beli byk2 bukan darurat dah kan?

Hang nak faham konsep dharurat dalam Islam kalu, hang dengaq dari minit 14:20 ni.....


Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register

Points Rules

 

ADVERTISEMENT



 

ADVERTISEMENT


 


ADVERTISEMENT
Follow Us

ADVERTISEMENT


Mobile|Archiver|Mobile*default|About Us|CARI Infonet

29-3-2024 08:13 PM GMT+8 , Processed in 0.700684 second(s), 42 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

Copyright © 2001-2021, Tencent Cloud.

Quick Reply To Top Return to the list