CARI Infonet

 Forgot password?
 Register

ADVERTISEMENT

View: 24594|Reply: 153

KRITIKAN seorang Cina tentang filem Melayu, "SUAMI AKU USTAZ"

  [Copy link]
Post time 19-5-2015 06:24 PM | Show all posts |Read mode
Wardina Safiyyah OfficialPage shared June Low's post.
1 hr ·

BACA dan FIKIR. Review of Suami Aku Ustaz.

June Low
7 hrs ·

I resisted the urge to do an angry review of Suami Aku Ustaz after watching it yesterday. Just bitched about it to a friend and decided to leave it at that because it had upset me enough and I wanted to let it go. But today, I woke up to more statutory rape in the news, and that just made me angrier. You know why this shit is happening? Because of movies like SUAMI AKU USTAZ that condone child marriages and put the perpetrators in good light.

The movie begins with parents who are going on haj. They decide they don't trust their 17 year old daughter to be alone at home while they're away, so instead of letting her crash at a relative’s house or whatever, they make the decision to shirk responsibility officially, and marry her off to her cousin, who just happens to be a religious teacher at her school.

There’s a scene where she is crying after they are married, and he is going on and on about how it was god’s will.

Adi Putra (who plays the creepiest religious teacher you can imagine) tells his new wife he won't force her to have sex with him until she is ready (how generous of him.) However, throughout the movie, he lays down a load of religious guilt on her, including telling her how a good wife is supposed to treat her husband in islam. He also incorporates this in his LESSON PLAN AT SCHOOL, questioning her in front of all the classmates (who don't yet know the two are married) In fact the only thing he seems interested in teaching during pendidikan agama is how to be a good wife.

In one scene she's hanging out with her mate at a paddy field, he is jealous and COMMANDS her to come home. He actually says "NOW" in an authoritative way and she reluctantly obeys. He also tells her she needs his permission to go out. In one scene, he won't give her permission because she doesn't want him to come along.

Early in their marriage, there's a scene where she's dancing to Kpop and then she wants to continue watching her Korean drama. He says "If you want to watch this, i can't stop you, but learn from it. Look how bad they are compared to us muslims and learn from it"

In the end, he gets arrested by the cops (who have responded to some student's facebook posting about their marriage on HIS FACEBOOK PAGE) and gets beat up in prison by other inmates. The girl goes to visit him in prison. Overnight, she has decided he is the best thing since sliced bread and the waterworks are on. The cops refuse to go on the basis of their sijil nikah, and in the end, her parents turn up, and her mom says "Dad is settling things with the cops"

Next scene, they are in the marital bed and he asks if she is willing and ready to be his wife, they embrace, and the movie ends.

Throughout the film he is portrayed as this fly guy, hot religious teacher, oppressing women for religious reasons. There's also one bit where after she says she gets on better with people her age, he gets a makeover and buys a super bike. There are slow mo shots highlighting how hot he is.

The amount of mindfuck in his movie is immense. There were 3 couples in the cinema with me, a pair of girls, and 3 loners. All malay except for me. Two of the couples were sat on the same row as me (FML) and kept talking and judging throughout the movie. Mainly when the girl was behaving “badly”.

A religious teacher marries an underaged girl, and he is portrayed as some kind of hero who’s too good for her?

Not to mention the inconsistencies! Under Ministry of Education guidelines, if you are married you cannot continue studying in a government school. However a girl can continue studying if she is pregnant but unmarried. (Don’t ask me, I don't understand it either.)

The entire movie relegates the legal age for marriage to nothing more than an unnecessary formality that can be done away with in the name of religion. Its main objective appears to be to put child marriages in good light, showing “a good side” to the buffet of statutory rape that has become a staple in the news. Old religious leader marries young girl? No problem! Watch this movie, not all of them want to rape underdeveloped bodies senseless! Don’t believe everything you read in the papers!

It is just horrifying propaganda - I noted how they are sneaky about legalities too. The way it’s been edited, there’s no way the audience can be sure if she’s of legal age at the point where they are on the marital bed about to have sex at the end of the movie. All we have seen is that he has not had sex with her up to that point, and so he is innocent DESPITE THE FACT THAT HE MARRIED A MINOR.

Shame on EVERYBODY who was involved in making this tripe. Where are the responses from the women’s rights organisations? Where is the Selective Women’s Aid Organisation? Sisters In Islam? YOU HAVE WORK TO DO.

Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 19-5-2015 06:30 PM | Show all posts
selayaknya lah. aku rasa filem melayu sekarang xde kualiti langsung. dala amik dari novel yg penulis dia penuh angan2 and budak2. masalahnya mentaliti sesetgh org yg menengoknya pun serupa. angan2 lebih jugak. tu yg kalau ada filem berkualiti, jarang org kita pegi tgk. malas pikir katanye.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 06:30 PM | Show all posts
hmm iols baca jugak ni, memang cite tu ntah hape2 tgk sinopsis pun.

moral pun kelaut. itu la filem2 masa kini, sampah
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 06:43 PM | Show all posts
Bace sinopsis pn dh tahu betapa smpah nye citer ni
Heran betul...dh ler drama2 pn amik dr novel
Filem pn mengikut jgak
Dah abes idea sgt ke
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 06:44 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Filem ni adalah salah satu bentuk wrong interpretation of hadith ... seolah2 nk menggambarkan bagaimana muhammad n aisyah sbg suami isteri di zmn moden. Penulis x bijak. Tu je meols boleh komen
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 06:57 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Producer dan director berlagak pandai. Buat malu kaum lain. Nmpk low class sgt wanuta di mata lelaki muslim ni:
Reply

Use magic Report

Follow Us
Post time 19-5-2015 07:05 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Lagilaa islam dipandang serong.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 07:16 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
There you go.i wonder y he choose to watch this movie.dah abis movie nk tgk ke dik?
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 19-5-2015 07:18 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
pedo cara lebih moden ( keagamaan) ..lagi nmpk hina islam di mata bukan islam..

mmg ada ummah kawin umur 14 tahun tpi bila cite begini di filemkan meyakinkan netizen yg ummah islam suka kawin budak...

memburukkan keadaan..plss stopp khayalan begini..lagi mengeletis la bebudak sekolah nak berlaki
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 07:19 PM | Show all posts
bila writer tak buat homework sebelum menulis, ni la jadinya. cheap story and adaptation.
timeline tak kena, wrong facts etc.. salah satu sebab novel2 sampah novelis2 berangan tak layak jadi adaptasi.

berangan tak salah, tak kena bayar pun. but why novelis2 kat negara kita taknak menulis like Habiburrahman El Shirazi?

Novel cinta sampah, anak orang kaya, kawen paksa etc tu dah lapuk. Enough is enough..

btw iols just baca a few malay novel, terutama Hlovate's books.. nice for starter.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 07:39 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Tggu kuar kt tv bru tgk...xbest tukar channel lain.xdelah bazir duit
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 07:55 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Erm ingatkan movie matsal mengarut,  movie melayu moslem lg teruk karut nya.  Sedeh
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 08:01 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Ni filem ke aku ingt mcm drama2 bodoh mcm isteri separuh masa tu. Yg tu lg hazab katanya ade phd doctorate tp bangang nak mampos asyik gaduh ngn bini bbnu.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 08:46 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
bbnu ska je flem ni....cmna la novel ni bleh jd best seller...storyline cliche...
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 08:54 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Uolls bbnu suka ceghita ghope ini aku x heran sgt.  Ni mak mak yg dah tua renta pon sibuk gak layan ceghita tak berapa nak empuk ni.  Siap pi opis dok story and speku apa yg akan jd episod akan dtg. Ujung ujung theyolls tanya iolls yg berhaluan kiri ni.  Iolls bagi sedas dua jek.  Lepas tu theyolls senyap terus.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 09:14 PM | Show all posts
keluar pilot cafe-kutuk
keluar suami aku ustaz- caci

tp filem 2 ni laku jgk kt wayang..da penat nk kutuk filem melayu sbb atlast dok tahap cenggitu je...producer ni wat bodo je ngn komen2 camni..ape je filem melayu best taun ni??dah stgh taun 2015 tp sume pon maaf ckp la..tahap sampah.

Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 19-5-2015 09:52 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Kerani tpt keja aku slaku mmber aku dok ajak2 aku tgk cite ni. Haiih. Aku mmg lemah btoi dgn cite melayu ni. Aritu dia ajak aku tgk mr perfect 10. Membazir wet aku. Suka btoi dia dgn drama melayu2 yg berangan cmnihhhh
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 09:56 PM | Show all posts
bohjan melayu suka bawak awek pprt mereka tgk drama2 melayu low class di pangung
bukan nya tengok sgt pun.. dok sibuk raba puki awek kat sebelah dalam gelap..
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 09:59 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Pilot cafe 2 iouls ok jek...sbb citer je menusuk ke hati sanubari iouls...nk2 plak abam pahrin sgt gojes jd pilot...iouls luluskn je citer 2...ada pengajaran kt si2...tp suami aku ustazzz???hadoiii...alasan nk kawinkn anak semata2 parents gi haji?apakahhhh??baca sinopsis je pon nk muntah dh...apatah lg klu g tgk wayang...
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-5-2015 10:02 PM | Show all posts
hahaha haritu aku teman kawan aku...dia belanja okeylah...kalau ikut aku mmg xla aku nk tgknye..

so, cerita ni mmg x logik pasal nk g haji kawinkan anak...gila la parents kalau befikiran cmni...ade banyak je cara lain kan..

pastu watak adi putra....bg aku mmg seram gak kalau ade ustaz ni..nmpk baik..tp menggunakan alasan dh jodoh ...kalau cmtu sonang la orang lain paksa kawin..pastu ckp dh jodoh..kalau aku silap maafkan aku..tp mmg la aku rase x logik langsung alasan dia
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register

Points Rules

 

ADVERTISEMENT



 

ADVERTISEMENT


 


ADVERTISEMENT
Follow Us

ADVERTISEMENT


Mobile|Archiver|Mobile*default|About Us|CARI Infonet

29-3-2024 11:52 PM GMT+8 , Processed in 0.075828 second(s), 46 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

Copyright © 2001-2021, Tencent Cloud.

Quick Reply To Top Return to the list