CARI Infonet

 Forgot password?
 Register

ADVERTISEMENT

View: 23255|Reply: 164

[Jenayah] Netizen Malaysia mencibir logo baru pariwisata Kuala Lumpur

[Copy link]
Post time 29-4-2016 08:00 AM | Show all posts |Read mode
Edited by bluehedgehog at 29-4-2016 05:21 PM

nak buat logo ni pakai Word Art kena caj RM15k...WTF....
siapa yg dpt kontrak buat logo ni...x smpai 5minit siap...dpt 15k....jilake



cuba la lihat design bandar lain:































Controversial KL logo costs RM15,000, says City Hall

BY NURUL HUDA JAMALUDDIN

KUALA LUMPUR, April 29 — The logo and brand master guide promoting Kuala Lumpur as a travel destination cost  RM15,000, the city’s Tourism Bureau general manager Noraza Yusof said.

Due to a budget cut in its branding exercise this year, City Hall’s tourism arm has no plans to change the logo for now despite the public ridicule, she said yesterday.

“The budget this year is very tight ... usually for this (branding), the cost could range between RM300,000 and RM1 million,” she said.

The logo and tagline, unveiled last Monday, was widely mocked after a magazine highlighted the design online and asked readers for their feedback.

Many questioned the cost, which some claimed to be amateur work that could be done on a computer in minutes.

Noraza said the overall branding exercise was budgeted at RM2.6 million, to be used for roadshows, media junkets and other promotional activities.

Of that sum, RM15,000 was spent on the brand master guide, comprising creation of the logo, tagline, description, rationale and strategy.

The logo features “Kuala Lumpur” in grey letters with a drop shadow, describing the city as “exciting, surprising and enticing”, and also brands it as a “city of contrasts and diversity”.

Noraza said diverse cultures and the juxtaposition of old and new were among the city’s strengths, and the branding focused on those.

The colour silver for the word Kuala Lumpur was meant to reflect the city’s tin mining roots, she said.

“We need to educate people and make them understand the brand first, the logo was only launched a few days ago,” she said.

She said the bureau welcomed criticism over the design.

“It is a good sign as it showes the KL-ites love their city,” she said.

She said the bureau hoped to increase tourist arrivals into the city to 12 million this year from 11.2 million last year, as well as raise revenue to RM60 billion from RM52 billion last year.

However, mayor Datuk Mhd Amin Nordin Abd Aziz said the logo design was not final.

“From time to time, we will improve on it. We are open to improvement. It can be discussed in the bureau’s quarterly meeting,” he said yesterday.

He said other cities like Amsterdam and New York took  years to fine-tune their logos.

He also said the logo was approved by the Federal Territories Minister Datuk Seri Tengku Adnan Tengku Mansor and industry players.

“It is not a one-man show. All  key players in the tourism industry are on the bureau’s advisory board,” he said.

The logo and branding initiative was based on findings of the Tourism Master Plan 2015-2025, which is under the responsibility of the bureau.

Amin said signs featuring the logo would be installed in three locations in Kuala Lumpur — at Dataran Merdeka, Bulatan Semantan and Jalan Sungai Besi.




KUALA LUMPUR, April 27 — A new logo and tagline to promote tourism in Kuala Lumpur has drawn online criticism from Malaysians, who poked fun at the design and the words used to describe their beloved capital city.

The logo, a simple design featuring “Kuala Lumpur” written in grey lettering with a drop shadow, describes the city as “exciting, surprising and enticing”, and also brands it as a “city of contrasts and diversity”.

According to reports, it was unveiled on Monday by mayor Datuk Seri Mhd Amin Nordin Abd Aziz.

Internet users were quick to mock the city’s new tourism promotion initiative.

Comments in a TimeOut article seeking readers’ feedback on the logo were overwhelmingly negative, with one commenter, Izwar Z, describing the logo as “shameful”.

“Looks like they designed it with PowerPoint,” wrote Aliff A, while another, Z K, described it as “embarrassing.”

“My mediocre sense of art never felt this insulted. We can’t do this to our city. Please don’t,” wrote Wahida Y.

Reaction on social networking sites such as Twitter was equally as negative, with one user, Faizal Hamssin, comparing the logo to those of Amsterdam’s, Jakarta, and Dubai.

“All are vibrant global cities. Now, can you see the difference?” he wrote.

Another Twitter user, Iced Nyior, recreated a similar logo with WordArt and posted it online, claiming it only took her five minutes to complete it.

“DBKL, I hope you didn’t pay lots for your new #kualalumpur branding as I did this in PPT with WordArt in 5 minutes,” the user wrote.

The Star in its article this week quoted Amin as saying that Kuala Lumpur needed its own branding in the same way Paris is associated with romance and Rio de Janeiro is associated with a carnival atmosphere.

“We need to create a brand for Kuala Lumpur, something that differentiates us from other cities,” he was quoted saying.

The logo signs will be installed in three locations in Kuala Lumpur — at Dataran Merdeka, Bulatan Semantan and Jalan Sungai Besi.

Malay Mail Online is currently trying to contact the KL City Hall for a response.


              





Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 29-4-2016 08:05 AM | Show all posts
baik bagi aku buat..
aku caj 50 hinggit... kira amal jariah
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:14 AM | Show all posts
as expected la kan... no wonder beriya2 nak rebrand bagai.... yang ini pun dah markup berapa
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:15 AM | Show all posts
#throwback


Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:23 AM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
atira replied at 29-4-2016 08:05 AM
baik bagi aku buat..
aku caj 50 hinggit... kira amal jariah

aku guna gimp pun bleh nih haha
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:30 AM | Show all posts
Of that sum, RM15,000 was spent on the brand master guide, comprising creation of the logo, tagline, description, rationale and strategy

mungkin pasal ada 3 yang kat belakang tu yang buat jadi mahal - description, rationale and strategy
Reply

Use magic Report

Follow Us
Post time 29-4-2016 08:33 AM | Show all posts
aku tak terperanjat dengan cost mcm tu.
pada aku normal aje untuk graphic agency charge macam ini.

bukan sebab city hall atau apa.. mana2 pun lebih kurang mcm ini..

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:35 AM | Show all posts
ni kalau bagi kat tapir senja siam buat pakai kaki petak dia sahaja boleh dapat berbelas ribu ringgit.

ni lagi satu contoh design2 low class yang wujud




Kete dah macam kete syarikat insurans.

Design logo tu bagi kat kawan anak2 you yang buat kah wahai Noraza Yusof? hapa punya tes laa.... sendu ya amat.
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


 Author| Post time 29-4-2016 08:35 AM | Show all posts
tentera_laut replied at 29-4-2016 08:33 AM
aku tak terperanjat dengan cost mcm tu.
pada aku normal aje untuk graphic agency charge macam ini.
...

word font mcm ni...baik x pyh buat....graphic agency siapa la yg buat font gini?




Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 29-4-2016 08:38 AM | Show all posts
lelakinaive replied at 29-4-2016 08:30 AM
Of that sum, RM15,000 was spent on the brand master guide, comprising creation of the logo, tagline, ...

yg pasti tukang buat font ni baru blajar design
sanggup pkai wordart window 95 buat design gini
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:38 AM | Show all posts
tentera_laut replied at 29-4-2016 08:33 AM
aku tak terperanjat dengan cost mcm tu.
pada aku normal aje untuk graphic agency charge macam ini.
...

cam budak wat part time job lps abis keje 9 to 5..x cam grafik agensi
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 29-4-2016 08:39 AM | Show all posts

ini kali jakarta menang
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:41 AM | Show all posts
bluehedgehog replied at 29-4-2016 08:35 AM
word font mcm ni...baik x pyh buat....graphic agency siapa la yg buat font gini?

selalunya proces.. agency akan bagi at least dalam 3 design pada client.. yg pilih adalah client. bukan salah agency. agency mampu aje buat yg boombastic punye design. atau yg clean and simple. diorang jugak buat search untuk pastikan design adalah unik and tak sama dengan org lain.

and design bukan direka menggunakan word. diorang sure guna graphic software. and hand over high resolution design.

design juga buka 1 aje.. selalu dtg dengan package untuk letter header, business card, sampul surat, untuk web, untuk mobile view. dan sebagainya.

bukan design 1 pakai word.. bagi client dapat rm 15k.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 08:45 AM | Show all posts
maybe yg tak pernah deal dengan agency mmg terperanjat dengan price mcm ni.
tp pada aku biasa saja. even freelance aku ada tgk 1 guy ni design 1 pic bentuk bumi yg cantek.. simple.. 1 aje.. die charge rm 1k..

so kalau deal dengan real agency 15 k.. pada aku biasa saja..

ala price art mmg cam ni.. subjective untuk di nilai.
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 29-4-2016 08:55 AM | Show all posts
tentera_laut replied at 29-4-2016 08:45 AM
maybe yg tak pernah deal dengan agency mmg terperanjat dengan price mcm ni.
tp pada aku biasa saja ...

lu jgn salah paham...
rm15k ke 100k ke mmg biasa
tp klau 15k atau 100k ataupun 1juta dgn hasil kje mcm budak sekolah rendah...sori la....
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 29-4-2016 08:55 AM | Show all posts
tentera_laut replied at 29-4-2016 08:41 AM
selalunya proces.. agency akan bagi at least dalam 3 design pada client.. yg pilih adalah client.  ...

harga x padan dgn hasil kje
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 29-4-2016 08:59 AM | Show all posts
bluehedgehog replied at 29-4-2016 08:55 AM
lu jgn salah paham...
rm15k ke 100k ke mmg biasa
tp klau 15k atau 100k ataupun 1juta dgn hasil k ...

aku dah ckp.. yg salah bukan agency.. yg PILIH masa Mock design tu siapa?
dah client pilih cam tu.. agency nak kata apa??? so issue rm 15k takde langsung.

i amsterdam logo kau kat atas tu pun simple sgt. Art very subjective.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 29-4-2016 09:00 AM | Show all posts
bluehedgehog replied at 29-4-2016 08:55 AM
harga x padan dgn hasil kje

siapa yg pilih masa mock?

Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 29-4-2016 09:01 AM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
tentera_laut replied at 29-4-2016 08:59 AM
aku dah ckp.. yg salah bukan agency.. yg PILIH masa Mock design tu siapa?
dah client pilih cam tu ...

Maksudnya semua tukang sign je la....
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 29-4-2016 09:02 AM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
tentera_laut replied at 29-4-2016 09:00 AM
siapa yg pilih masa mock?

Nape tanya qu plak...qu x kje di dbkl...
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register

Points Rules

 

ADVERTISEMENT



 

ADVERTISEMENT


 


ADVERTISEMENT
Follow Us

ADVERTISEMENT


Mobile|Archiver|Mobile*default|About Us|CARI Infonet

19-4-2024 07:16 AM GMT+8 , Processed in 0.312046 second(s), 46 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

Copyright © 2001-2021, Tencent Cloud.

Quick Reply To Top Return to the list