MBPJ di kritik dedahkan maklumat pengadu

Chekpa

Shock over PJ council’s policy of disclosing complainant’s identity[color=rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.6)]Soo Wern Jun

[color=rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.701961)]

[color=rgb(255, 255, 255) !important][size=14.399999618530273px]Share[color=rgb(255, 255, 255) !important][size=14.399999618530273px]Tweet[color=rgb(255, 255, 255) !important][size=14.399999618530273px]Pin[color=rgb(255, 255, 255) !important][size=14.399999618530273px]Mail

[size=12.800000190734863px]Cynthia Hor filed a complaint with MBPJ over fears of a landslide occurring at a construction site near her house in Damansara Perdana, Petaling Jaya.

PETALING JAYA: The Petaling Jaya City Council (MBPJ) has been criticised for revealing confidential details of a resident to a developer against whom she had filed a complaint over construction work near her house.
Cynthia Hor, a resident of Damansara Perdana, was shocked to find that her full name and address had been given in a letter by the council’s Engineering Department, demanding an explanation from the developer, Mammoth Empire Holding Sdn Bhd.
“Did they have to disclose my name and home address?” she asked.
Hor said this was a violation of the Whistleblower Protection Act 2010, which provides protection to those who voluntarily come forward to report wrongdoings.
The act among others prohibits the disclosure of a complainant’s confidential information, including the name and address.
“I only wanted MBPJ to come and check if what I see could be a trigger to a possible landslide,” Hor told FMT.
“Each time it rains, I see a little more vegetation disappear. I was worried that if that area is prone to a massive landslide, someone needs to do something about it.”



Hor questioned MBPJ’s intention in disclosing her name and address to the developer, saying it served no purpose in the investigation.
A copy of the letter was also sent to her.

[size=12.800000190734863px]The letter from MBPJ to developer Mammoth Empire Holding Sdn Bhd, complete with Cynthia Hor’s full name and address.

Hor said if MBPJ could not guarantee the confidentiality of a complainant, “nobody will come forward to do their civic duty”.
“It is no different from a person lodging a report about his neighbour who is abusive, and when the authorities decide to take action, they disclose who made the report,” she said.
But MBPJ’s Engineering Department director, Ismail Shafie, said there was nothing wrong in disclosing the name and home address of a complainant.
Ismail told MBPJ councillor Sean Oon that the developer needed to know who the complainant was “in order to verify the legitimacy of the location”.
“He also said this was not a personal complaint, but a complaint that involves the public, therefore there is no issue in disclosing the identity of the complainant.
“He obviously does not understand the concept of respecting a complainant’s privacy. In this case, Cynthia acted as a whistleblower and her identity should be protected,” Oon told FMT.
Oon said MBPJ should have asked Hor’s permission before revealing her identity to the developer.
“Is this how they treat every complainant who lodges a report with MBPJ? Is this their standard operating procedure?
“If this is how they handle whistleblowers, I’m afraid not many people will dare come forward to voice their complaints in the future, for fear of their identity being disclosed in this manner and jeopardising their safety,” he said.

Chekpa

MBPJ under fire for revealing identity of complainant to developer

• [/url]
  
• [url=https://twitter.com/share?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.edgeprop.my%2Fcontent%2F1286354%2Fmbpj-under-fire-revealing-identity-complainant-developer&via=twitterdev&related=twitterapi%2Ctwitter&hashtags=EdgeProp.my%2CtheEdge&text=]
  
• [/url]
  
• [url=whatsapp://send?text=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.edgeprop.my%2Fcontent%2F1286354%2Fmbpj-under-fire-revealing-identity-complainant-developer]
  
• [url=][size=2.8][/url]
  

[color=rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.8)][size=1.6]

[size=1.4]By [url=]EDGEPROP.MY[/url]
[size=1.2]Fri, 23 Feb 2018 1:10 pm

PETALING JAYA (Feb 23): Majlis Perbandaran Petaling Jaya (MBPJ) has been lambasted for releasing personal information of a resident who had complained against construction work near her home, which has sparked privacy concerns that may silence future complainants.

In a report by Free Malaysia Today (FMT), Damansara Perdana resident Cynthia Hor was shocked to find out that the council’s engineering department had sent a letter to developer Mammoth Empire Holding Sdn Bhd, complete with her full name and home address.

Questioning the need for her particulars to be included in the letter, she added that this was a breach of the Whistleblower Protection Act 2010, which protects those who voluntarily report wrong doings — including the disclosure of their personal details, such as their name and address.

“I only wanted MBPJ to come and check if what I see could be a trigger to a possible landslide,” she told the portal.

“Each time it rains, I see a little more vegetation disappear. I was worried that if that area is prone to a massive landslide, someone needs to do something about it,” she added.

She said it was unlikely that people would come forward to perform their civic duty if MBPJ could not guarantee the privacy of a complainant — a sentiment echoed by MBPJ councillor Sean Oon.

“Is this how they treat every complainant who lodges a report with MBPJ? Is this their standard operating procedure?

“If this is how they handle whistleblowers, I’m afraid not many people will not dare come forward to voice their complaints in the future, for fear of their identity being disclosed in this manner and jeopardising their safety,” he said.

He added that the council should have sought Hor’s permission before disclosing her particulars to Mammoth Empire Holding.

However, MBJP’s Engineering Department director Ismail Shafie told Oon that the developer should know who the complainant is “in order to verify the legitimacy of the location”.

“He also said this was not a personal complaint, but a complaint that involves the public, therefore there is no issue in disclosing the identity of the complainant,” he said.

MAJLIS PERBANDARAN PETALING JAYAMBPJDAMANSARA PERDANAMAMMOTH EMPIRE HOLDINGWHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTION ACT 2010

Clan204

Kes kebocoran data sebelum nh mcmc dah dapat tangkap sapa yang buat tak?

batmana

“He also said this was not a personal complaint, but a complaint that involves the public, therefore there is no issue in disclosing the identity of the complainant,” he said.

no issue atuk ko.
cube dedahkan pula alamat staff dorg ,Ismail Shafie, sebab nk tau samada ismail ni wujud ke tak kt MBJP

bit

Clan204 replied at 24-2-2018 11:51 AM
Kes kebocoran data sebelum nh mcmc dah dapat tangkap sapa yang buat tak?

Katanya yg bocor tu company yg dilantik MCMC (kompeni kroni) utk bg block cellular service. Itu yg senyap je.

amira_safia

Pengkuatkuasa MBPJ sekarang ni pemalas, dah banyak aduan pun tak peduli tapi bila MBPJ reply email tulis dah amik tindakan padahal haram tak buat apa pun.

Lebih baik masa BN berkuasa ... kawasan bersih, selalu penguatkuasa akan ambil tindakan bila aduan dibuat ... zaman PKR ni kawasan kotor, gerai2 haram banyak dll.

bit

Cuba la gugle Nuemera Sdn Bhd

Clan204

bit replied at 24-2-2018 12:00 PM
Cuba la gugle Nuemera Sdn Bhd

Kroni2 jugak la yang buat... Mcm tu memang tada guna la semua agensi yg jaga dan simpan data nh... Wayang je semua

Skuau

amira_safia replied at 24-2-2018 12:00 PM
Pengkuatkuasa MBPJ sekarang ni pemalas, dah banyak aduan pun tak peduli tapi bila MBPJ reply email t ...

bersepah gerai warga asing kat bandar sunway....bandaraya pigi mana da???

krustykrab

Sbb tu org takut nk jadi whistleblower

fofuler

Si Ismail ni tak tau konsep whistleblower ke apa? Anyhow kat negara tercinta kita ni, aku tak caya dengan konsep ni, takleh pakai. Personal data bocor pun boleh sapu bawah karpet lagi

swimswim

Hmmm tetiba jujur la plak pbt ni

~boolean

Jadi mbpj tak siasat aduan tu kan? Sebab tu mbpj beri maklumat peribadi supaya developer sendiri 'pergi tengok' kawasan aduan tu? Begitu?

Lepas tu boleh pula beri alasan macam tak bersalah?

gekkou

jadi sekarang MBPJ kena tengok balik maksud whistleblower ke macam mana ni?
sean oon (MBPJ Councillor) kata tak patut reveal
Ismail plak cakap normal kalau reveal
ismail ni dah suruh team dia pergi check lokasi yang dilaporkan itu ke belum?
ke memang cara kerja minta pemaju check sendiri
maaf aku tak nampak isi kandungan surat yang dihantar tu


but, risau juga kan bila nama dan alamat kena reveal mcm tu
pemaju kalau bengang mungkin akan ambil tindakan tidak sepatutnya kepada pengadu
tapi betul juga kita pun tatau report yang macam mana dikira rahsia yang mana satu pula dikira for public purpose

Chekpa

~boolean replied at 24-2-2018 06:51 PM
Jadi mbpj tak siasat aduan tu kan? Sebab tu mbpj beri maklumat peribadi supaya developer sendiri 'pe ...

Dorang luluskan projek tepi cerun...
Pastu org situ complaint antar notis je kat developer buat siasatan..
Abistu mbpj buat apa?

cmf_shalom

MBPJ gila ke apa..

Mana boleh reveal pengadu ..Tu kerja pihak Majlis la sama ada aduan tu ada asas ke X...

amira_safia

Skuau replied at 24-2-2018 05:31 PM
bersepah gerai warga asing kat bandar sunway....bandaraya pigi mana da???

dorang buat bodoh je ...

leylapple

saman jer mpsj nie..

OrenTheReturn

Hanjenggs sgttt mentality safie ismail ni, instead of mengaku salah n say sorry bla bla bla dia sanggop mati2 nak pertahankan tindakan mcm org taksekolah agensi dia tu.....org mcm ni yach yg diberi tanggungjwb tadbir agensi mcm ni huh. Mana picca bangsatttt ni? malukan dia kat cariiii.....kita pakat2 bagi hukuman donia dulu

OrenTheReturn