Hang tuah mitos atau lagenda?

lows^man^lyrics

sorry kalau thread ni dah ada..saja terfikir betulke hang tuah wujud?kalau wujud mana kuburnya..

a.ceCCo

mitos.....

fleurzsa

IMO... Hang Tuah tu memang wujud tetapi cerita mengenai beliau terlalu bombastik..

Biasa la pengarang Melayu dulu2 suka melebih2...

So kira legenda la kot..

ruffly_sya

rasanya lagenda...

stripper_j

kalau mahsuri ada keturunannya..hang tuah tak de..eh betul ker?

usagiKecik

mcm mitos je...sbb xde bukti dia pernah wujud

lows^man^lyrics

yg paling lawak dan kelakar,cite pasal sesiapa jumpa keris tamingsari tandanya hang tuah masih hidup..:no:

raeshad

tu ha...kat melaka tu kan ada :bgrin:

anyway, it's a legend. how so?

here:

a myth gives a religious explanation for something: how the world or a particular custom began. There is usually no attempt to fix the myth into a coherent chronology related to the present day, though myths or a cycle of myths may have their own internal chronology. The story is timeless in that the events are symbolic rather than just the way it happened.

A legend, on the other hand, is a story which is told as if it were a historical event, rather than as an explanation for something or a symbolic narrative. The legend may or may not be an elaborated version of a historical event. Thus, examples of legends are the stories about Robin Hood and Hang Tuah :bgrin:

Hang Tuah menepati ciri2 legenda. bukannye mitos....eh heh......interesting question nonetheless......

lagenda.  

benda ni turun dari turun temurun. mulut ke mulut.

hang tuah dikatakan tiada waris kerna dia lari selepas bunuh jebat & tidak diketahui ke mana dia pergi.

mahsuri lain ceritanya kerna anak dia dibawa ke siam.

Syd

lagenda.
penah wujud
tapi citer ttg dia ni rasanya mmg ditulis dan diwar2kan melebihi apa yang sepatutnya

zulyha

mitos la..

kempot

lagendaaaaa kot.....

yaneng

apa beza mitos n legenda.....

OrhanGhazi

Sedihnya, pasal sejarah Hang Tuah pun ada lagi orang melayu anggap ianya mitos. Kalo Hang Tuah tu mitos, Sultan Mansor Syah tu pun leh dikira mitos, Tun Perak pun leh kira mitos jgk..sbb diorang pun antara watak utama dalam kisah Hang Tuah. Kalo diorang tu suma mitos..Melaka tu pun mitos jugak..so at last, orang Melayu dah tak de menda lagi yang nak dibanggakan melalui sejarah silamnya sebab sume tu hanyalah mitoooosssss...

askRULE

aku ade terbaca majalah mastika (dlm thun nie gak kut..lupe la)...

ade sorang pakcik nie ckp sbnarnye hang tuah nie sorang perempuan

yakin giler pakcik tue ckp

mayong

aku rasa mungkin dia wujud, tapi cerita pasal dia tu terlalu digembar gemburkan..
kadang2 cam x logik pun ada..