Findings collision between ANL Indonesia and RSS Courageous

tangopapa

4 April 2003
                    
Findings of the Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA)'s  inquiry into the collision between ANL Indonesia and RSS Courageous

http://www.channelnewsasia.com/courageous/030404_mparpt2.htm

tangopapa

Conclusions

The collision between AI and RC was caused  by errors of judgement in assessing the situation and the wrongful application of the Collision Regulations on the part of RC. Although the trainee OOW had the "control of the ship", the trainee was at all times under the OOW's supervision. According to RSN regulations, the OOW of RC was in charge of the watch and not the trainee OOW. As such, the OOW was fully responsible for the safe navigation of RC.By not intervening, the OOW had shown that he was either not fully aware of the situation around him or had wrongly agreed with the actions and instructions given by the trainee OOW. Thus, the OOW of RC had either failed to keep a proper watch or had made similar errors of judgement as the trainee OOW. When RC stayed in the eastbound lane after making a "U" turn from its original course of 050

razhar

sejak bila lu jadi jurucakap RS navy?

tangopapa

Baru appointed....gaji berjuta2 lemon...

Robotech

Kira human error lah nih ... costly mistake beb, nyawa fellow comrade gak melayang .....

tangopapa

How in the world they let trainees control the ship...modern ships = poor handlings...

tin

aiseyyy... depa bayaq hang dgn lemon je? camno nak idup? lu dah jumpa ke distributor untuk kasik jual lu punya lemon berjuta tuh?

tin

no. the question is how the hell did the OOW failed to keep a proper watch and made similar errors of judgement as the trainee OOW.

so who's the bad decision maker, the OOW or the trainee?

[ Last edited by  tin at 21-8-2007 08:48 AM ]

zulupapa

may be both of them

IceMallet

Ini yang depa nak pakai utk serang kita?..Huhuhuhu

ef/x

Kokap ?

IceMallet

Findings collision between ANL Indonesia and RSS Courageous - NS seamen are crap and should be told to stop arse-banging each other while on duty...

Debmey

its not the NS men, its the regulars.

jazim

RSN and RSAF had more regulars than Sg Army, which in contrast had more NSmen

[ Last edited by  jazim at 21-8-2007 10:04 PM ]

IceMallet

Forgive me then..

Findings collision between ANL Indonesia and RSS Courageous - SG regular seamen are crap and should be told to stop arse-banging each other while on duty...

powerwoot

siol betul

kapakterbang

tak silap aku TLDM pon ada eksiden cam nih kan? langgar kapal nelayan thailand? kd raja jarom ke kd bangi ke kd ape tah.. tp takde yg mati la.. taun 1985 kot eksiden nih..

mentosonline

Everyone makes mistakes la.
You mean Malaysian navy never make any mistakes leh?

powerwoot

Yup, we all did some mistakes. Maybe the discussion here is about some mistake that should not suppose to happened, RSS Courageous is a modern navy ship which equipped with sophisticated detection devices and ANL Indonesia is no small vessel, unless it is a small fishing boat then it will be different story.

pcboss

kapal indo tu stleath sebenarnya..